Redeemer University - Christian university changes everything. Starting with you.            Shure-wireless-excellence  Shure-wireless-excellence
Skip Navigation Links
Seeking God?

Visit this room to gather, learn and share with the Body of Christ

Thoughts and Concerns about Emerging Ideas
A conversation about emerging church ideas: Do they achieve what they hope to, or purport to achieve?

These are some thoughts that I, a 30-year-old youth pastor, have been thinking about in terms of the emerging church. I hesitate to dip my toe into the deep waters, but I might as well jump in head first. The following are my thoughts and concerns that come out of my desire to grasp how God is moving in our world. If there is an indictment here it is of myself—because I have, at one point or another, ascribed my thinking to all the issues that follow.

I hear from emerging church leaders that the key to our future will be found in revisiting the past.

Revisiting the past

I hear from emerging church leaders that the key to our future will be found in revisiting the past. If we would only look to what the "ancient" church did, we will see a window into Jesus' intent for what we really should be as a community. It is an "ancient-future" mindset. Basically it is a wholesale rejection of the modern form of church and a desire to pick up where the Renaissance left off.

Revisiting ancient worship

Some seek to connect our current culture with "ancient" worship experiences. This often provides the participant with a profound mystical worship experience. It is an otherworldly retreat from the hectic pace of our North American culture.

It may be dangerous to assume that we can have a concept today of the reality of ancient forms of worship. At best we have our own self-constructed feeling of what it was like. We also have no idea if those forms of worship served to focus the church on mission, or simply contributed to a growing sense of disengagement and separation of the laity from the form and function of Church ministry.

Secondly, the desire to recreate ancient forms of worship can tend toward the desire to find integrity and authenticity out of a seeming participation in an ancient faith, rather than a church that seeks after the reality of God's current movements within our own culture. It is a playing at older forms of dress, language and movement. If our authenticity is found in what we do, as opposed to who we truly are, then worship becomes theatre as we seek to act in ways that make us appear to have traveled through time to call the church back to "the way it was."

Thirdly, we may be placing the reality of Christian experience in a constructed ancient culture which may constrain our faith to a separate constructed reality. If our worship and faith experience is founded in a culture that no longer exists, then we have a faith that gets lost in the grind of daily life in the 21st century. The problem that the emerging church is attempting to avoid—a modern church disconnected from current cultural realities—is compounded by an even more culturally distant and self-created expression of divine encounter.

This expression of ancient in modern is typified by a recent emerging church video that I saw in which someone played the U2 video Vertigo. For the first three-quarters of the video they had included frenetic images of our current reality [downtown New York Iraq war images, smog, cars on a freeway, etc.]. The last quarter was overlaid with images from some Jesus movie with Jesus slowly walking through the desert saying nice things, all the while U2 playing heavy in the background. This was presented as a great "post-modern" expression connecting Jesus with today's reality. The problem was that Jesus could not have seemed any more disconnected from the loud, industrialized frenzy of modern society. How could someone caught in the midst of all the chaos see a white guy walking the desert 2000 years ago as someone who understands and empathizes with them?

Where is our modern reality of Jesus? Where is the Jesus who drives a car? Where is the Jesus who knows what it is to be "downsized" by a faceless corporation? If we don't have a reality of Jesus in this culture, then this culture will never embrace the reality of Jesus. Sorry for the bumper sticker formulation of the last statement. I believe in a Jesus who 2000 years ago died on a cross and rose from the dead, but that can't be the end of it. To truly be the church, we need to believe in a Jesus who is manifested here and now. If we can't see Him now, we will never effectively communicate Him now.

Revisiting art

There was a time, not so long ago, when I bought into the phrase "O for the days when the church was the greatest patron of the arts." It didn't take a long look at church history to see that those were the days when the church became so focused on attaining beauty and wealth for themselves that they completely disengaged from doing the ministry that Jesus modelled. How many were starving and dying when the church was pouring their resources into paintings, sculpture and music? Don't get me wrong, I like and appreciate art. I just hope that if it comes to having a new piece of art or feeding the homeless guy on the church steps, that I will always, always choose the latter.

… the "emerging church" is not as far from the mega-church model as it tends to think.

If our churches are about art, music, or anything other than the mission that God has called us to, we will cease to be a church and instead become a storehouse of earthy treasure. We will become like the great big beautiful ancient churches of Europe where the insides are adorned with every kind of priceless artefact. They lack nothing but the most priceless artefact of all, people.

Function or form have a feeling that the "emerging church" is not as far from the mega-church model as it tends to think. I am concerned, in talking to many emerging church planters, that there is a very modern church response to the question, What does your church do? I hear responses like:

We are a house church.
We are a pub church.
We are music driven.
We never do music.
We are an arts church.
We use a lectionary.
We don't use a lectionary.
We don't preach.

My concern is that the "emerging church" is leaning heavily toward form over function. The search of relevancy is being found in the externals.

Willow Creek Church is often used as an example of the emerging church of a "customer" driven, all flash and little substance type of church. If the emerging church focuses its energy on doing Sunday differently to draw people in our culture, then they are doing that which they denigrate. I feel strongly that God is calling young men and women to be Christ to a community and let that community organically find their expression of worship to God. I do not believe that God calls us to worship Him in a set way and then see if anyone comes. Jesus' function in the world was not to worship God as ministry, but to worship God in ministry. If God's desire was for us to solely worship Him, He would make us do it. God desires men and women who, out of a transforming relationship with Him, seek to love and serve the world. That is our greatest act of worship. Our form should never dictate our function; it's the other way around.

A new church plant should invest every bit of their time into who God is calling them to, and how God is calling them to reach those people. A church plant that discusses Sunday morning before it discusses Sunday afternoon to Saturday night is looking to cater to its own personal liturgical preferences. It is more a reaction to modern Christianity than it is a theology for a given culture.

More on Emerging Churches? Visit "Are We an Emerging Church?" by Dr. Phil Zylla. Are there shifts occurring in your church toward an Emerging Church profile?

Paul Millar is the youth pastor at Arlington Woods Free Methodist Church in Ottawa, Ontario.

Originally published in Mosaic, Spring 2007.




  • Redeemer University - Christian university changes everything. Starting with you.

Visit our Marketplace

Support the EFC ministry by using our Amazon links